Skip to the text

Eighteen hotels that
argue with the street

Every building here disagrees with its neighbours about something. This guide takes eighteen hotels and resorts and asks what each one refuses to copy from the buildings around it, and what it takes from them anyway.

A gold numeral 10 in a circular metal emblem, with a roulette wheel, playing cards and gears on dark green cloth.

Every entry is written the same way. The first block sets out what the building argues with, in form, material, colour or age. The second sets out what it agrees with, because almost every building keeps something from its street: a line, a roof, a stone, a slope. The third describes how the difference is settled on the ground, through a setback, a yard or a base. The method is set out in full on The Disagreement.

The eighteen

Water built where wood normally stands

Snow walls beside glass domes in forest

A yearly building among permanent shore houses

A snow fortress on a working waterfront

Identical berths inside a shophouse frame

One white unit repeated in a controlled city

Sleeping niches cut into book shelving

Bath floors held in dense station-side building

A glass wedge among brick dock buildings

Green house fronts stacked into one block

An oval tower in a right-angled quarter

Oval windows in a square-windowed old centre

Glass wings joined to an 1899 house

A 1928 stone bank among glass offices

Expo pavilions reused on a park island

A large resort along a natural gorge

A resort with moorings on a working river

One large roof in lake and forest country